Quakers in Criminal Justice Conference 2025
Future Directions and Unheard Voices
The weekend was packed with speakers, workshops, small groups and even entertainment from singer songwriter ‘Nudges and Winks’.
Friday
Session 1 (PDF) comprised a thoughtful talk by Phil Bowen, Director of the Centre for Justice Innovation. Addressing the future of the criminal justice system he spoke about the potential uses (and misuses) of A.I within criminal justice and advocated for community led responses for the twin aims of repairing harm and rehabilitation.
Saturday
Session 2 took the form of a Panel to update us on current concerns. Mike Nellis alerted us to the new technology that appears to replace functions of the Probation Service, removing the human and empathetic elements. His paper (PDF) flagged up the government's keenness on ‘AI-powered change’ without a thorough consideration of ethical issues. We were reminded of the Just Algorithms Action Group, now collaborating with QICJ, which is seeking to raise awareness of inherent problems in relying on AI-generated algorithms.
Liz Bridges has been leading the Wandsworth Prison Improvement Campaign since she was banned from the prison where she was working as a Quaker Chaplain. We heard about prisoners’ living conditions, the culture of machismo and rudeness including amongst staff and the failure of basic systems, in one case resulting directly in the suicide of an inmate. The Campaign continues to lobby and keep the pressure on the Governor and MOJ.
Ann Horton talked about UNGRIPP, the United Group for Reform of Imprisonment for Public Protection (IPP), a small grassroots campaign challenging this discredited sentence and supporting affected families. Ann shared statistics (PDF) and further information (PDF).
Kate Fraser is Head of Practice for Women in Prison and responsible for their magazine. She informed us of prisons and risk assessment tools designed for men which are not fit for purpose for women. Katie welcomed the introduction of the Women’s Justice Board and long-awaited recommendations that young girls will no longer be sent to young offenders’ institutions and domestic abuse will be considered a mitigating factor. The term ‘relentless botheration‘ was coined for these three tireless women campaigners. Their resilience encourages hope, even where it was hard to see where hope survives.
Workshops comprised Women in Prison and IPP families. In the latter we heard of Ann Horton’s personal experience of her adopted grandson who has been serving an IPP sentence for the last 15 years following an initial 3-year tariff. She told us of a catalogue of moving prisons, losing clothing, changes in parole dates without warning, lack of mental health support and lack of guidance on the expectation the CJS has on IPP prisoners so they can work towards release.
Finally, we were very moved to hear a first-hand account of the experience of a victim of crime. Two members of Amandip Kaur’s family were murdered. She spoke of her grief and the official processes provided to victims. This is an area QICJ has neglected over the years.
Sunday
The focus was on the discernment of the Quakers in the CJ working group on safely integrating former prisoners into Quaker Meetings. Welcoming All (PDF) is now being widely circulated.
Our conference paid tribute to the lifelong service of Martin Wright, much-loved member of QICJ, and former Director of the Howard League. Martin was prominent in penal reform and restorative justice. See Restorative Justice for All's tribute to him.
Over the weekend we were treated to yoga sessions from Selina Sasse, Director of the Prison Phoenix Trust.
Sue Penna
Cornwall Area Meeting